by Amaranth
selwyth wrote:
The card system is (fiddly) randomization with replacement while a dice system is (easy and aesthetically pleasing) randomization without replacement.
You'd need 4 different types of D30 to get roughly the same probabilities. That seems way more fiddly, difficult, time-consuming and eyestrain-inducing than the card system, and you wouldn't get the hidden information aspect of decision making in combat that you get with the card system.
And that milling a fate card for each die rolled idea just sounds like trolling.